It has been a whirlwind week for Stranger Things star Gaten Matarazzo. Fresh off the emotional series finale of the Netflix juggernaut earlier this month, the 23-year-old actor is back in the headlines for two very different reasons: a legitimate new movie premiere in Syracuse, New York, and a bizarre viral rumor involving Michael B. Jordan.
If you’re scrolling through Twitter trying to separate fact from fiction regarding the “Sinners: Legacy” casting, you aren’t alone. We have the full breakdown below.
The New Syracuse Movie Premiere
While the internet argues over fake casting news, Gaten Matarazzo is celebrating a very real achievement. Syracuse.com reported just 10 hours ago that his new film, a “transformative quest” comedy, has officially announced its premiere.
The Project: “Untitled BriTANicK Comedy”
Filming Location: Syracuse, NY (American High Studios)
Genre: College Stoner Comedy / Adventure
The Plot: Matarazzo stars as a college student who, along with a friend (played by Sean Giambrone), orders a pizza during a bad drug trip. The simple task of retrieving the pizza downstairs becomes an epic, mind-bending odyssey.
This project marks a significant shift for Matarazzo, moving from the sci-fi horror of Hawkins to R-rated comedy. Produced by Hulu and American High, the film is expected to leverage Matarazzo’s comedic timing, which fans loved in early seasons of Stranger Things.
His move into indie comedy mirrors the career pivots of other young stars. For example, you can see how other actors manage their post-franchise careers in this Tom Holland news update, as he balances Spider-Man with serious drama.
Debunked: The ‘Sinners’ Replacement Rumor
Yesterday, a viral tweet claimed that Gaten Matarazzo would be replacing Michael B. Jordan in a sequel titled Sinners: Legacy, allegedly taking over the roles of “Smoke” and “Stack.” This claim is 100% False.
❌ FACT CHECK: FALSE
The Source: The rumor originated from a parody account on X (formerly Twitter) named “Discussing Fish,” which mimics the reputable news source “DiscussingFilm.”
The Reality: Director Ryan Coogler has explicitly stated there are no plans for a sequel to the 2025 hit Sinners. Furthermore, the idea of Matarazzo replacing Jordan in a gritty vampire period piece was intended as satire.
While the tweet garnered over 60,000 likes, it highlights the ease with which misinformation spreads. This situation is similar to the constant churn of Timothée Chalamet rumors that often turn out to be baseless fan speculation.
Join the Hellfire Club
Rep the iconic club from Stranger Things Season 4. The perfect casual tee for fans of Dustin Henderson.
Check PriceLife After Stranger Things
With the final episodes of Stranger Things Season 5 dropping on January 1, 2026, Matarazzo is officially moving on from the role of Dustin Henderson. The finale left Dustin in a poignant place—grappling with the loss of Eddie Munson and his own maturity.
Matarazzo has been vocal about wanting to explore diverse roles, including returning to his roots in theater. Just as Zendaya’s biography shows a successful transition from Disney to HBO, Matarazzo is poised to redefine his public image beyond “the kid with the hat.”
Return to the Stage?
Before television fame, Matarazzo was a Broadway kid, starring in Les Misérables. Industry insiders speculate a return to the New York stage is imminent in 2026. This dedication to craft is shared by many committed actors; for instance, reading about Jeremy Allen White’s routine reveals the physical dedication required for top-tier roles.
See Gaten’s Roots
Gaten Matarazzo started in Les Mis. Experience the legendary musical that launched his career.
View DVD/Blu-rayFrequently Asked Questions
No. The viral tweet claiming he would replace Michael B. Jordan was a joke posted by a parody account. There is no sequel currently in production.
It is an untitled comedy produced by American High and Hulu. The plot involves a college pizza delivery that turns into a “transformative quest.”
Yes. The final batch of Season 5 episodes was released in late 2025/early 2026, concluding the main series storyline.
He is focusing on indie films (like the Syracuse project) and is expected to pursue more theater work on Broadway.